Content Marketing 8 min readMarch 2025 By OwlClaw Team

Content Audit: How to Find and Fix Your Underperforming Content

How to conduct a content audit — inventorying your content, identifying top performers, diagnosing underperformers, and creating a content improvement roadmap.

Content AuditSEOContent Strategy

Key Takeaways

  • Content Inventory
  • The Four Content Decisions
  • Prioritizing Updates

A content audit is a systematic evaluation of every piece of content on your website — identifying what is working, what is underperforming, and what should be updated, merged, or removed. Regular content audits are essential for maintaining SEO health and content quality at scale.

Content Inventory

Use Screaming Frog or ContentKing to crawl your site and export a list of all URLs. For each URL, gather: monthly organic sessions (Google Search Console), page engagement rate (GA4), number of backlinks (Ahrefs), and published date. This creates your audit database.

The Four Content Decisions

Keep and improve (strong traffic, strong engagement), Consolidate (similar pages targeting the same keyword — merge into one), Update (good topic, outdated content — refresh and republish), Delete and redirect (thin content with no traffic, no backlinks, and no business value — 404 and redirect to related content).

Prioritizing Updates

Focus update effort on: pages with top 25% traffic that have declined in the last 6 months (high impact), pages ranking positions 6–15 for target keywords (close to page 1, worth a push), and pages with high impressions but low CTR in Search Console (fix meta titles and descriptions).

Quick Facts

3–6 mo
Avg. time to see results
150+
Clients helped
3x
Average ROI improvement
98%
Client retention rate
10+
Years combined expertise
Free
Initial strategy audit
O
OwlClaw Team
SEO Content Strategist · OwlClaw Technologies

The OwlClaw team brings together specialists in SEO, paid media, social marketing, and AI automation — delivering measurable growth for 150+ businesses across India.

Share this articleTwitter / XLinkedIn

Content Marketing FAQs

Full content audit every 12 months. Quarterly check-in on your top 20 traffic pages. After every major Google Core Update, review pages that lost significant organic traffic — these likely need quality improvements to recover.

Free Consultation Available

Ready to Put These Strategies to Work?

Get a free consultation with an OwlClaw strategist and build a custom plan for your business.

No credit card required. Response within 2 business hours.